Wednesday, 13 January 2010

(Un)intelligent Design

The title of this bulletin pays homage to the title of a chapter in Richard Dawkins' book, The Greatest Show on Earth.  Very vivid description of evolution, quite striking in places, although still suffering from his normal vanity and name-dropping.  But he describes the way in which evolution proceeds - first by a leap forward and then by fine-tuning and tinkering to make up for the flaws in the original jump.  The flaws being retained, but the fine-tuning making up for them - as in the compensation for upside-down vision or the blind spot in the eye, or eyeless fish in caves.
Which makes me very worried.

If that's how things work - giant change, then bodge and fiddle afterwards to iron out the glitches - I can only conclude that God is a computer programmer.  How scary is that?  So when it's time for the next big evolutionary leap forward - let's hope he's not set for a late night and sending out for pizza.  I can imagine him making all those design decisions, patching them up - and then coming in late next morning thinking "well it's not perfect, but it's live now."

2 comments :

  1. Interesting concept - God AKA Microsoft.

    When you consider Windows Vista - your allegory sounds pretty much like the production and implementation of Vista.

    Perhaps Professor Dawkins is a Bill Gate's clone - explaining how things work. I would not be surprised.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So far Dawkins has managed to avoid one major 'Gates' error... that paperclip that pops up and states the obvious before offering unnecessary help.

    ReplyDelete

Drop a thoughtful pebble in the comments bowl